Morocco’s PJD: what has the party learned from its dramatic fall

Mainstream Narrative

Al Jazeera frames this as a political comeback story: Morocco's Justice and Development Party (PJD), an Islamist party, suffered a stunning electoral collapse in 2021 but is now attempting to rebuild under its charismatic former leader Abdelilah Benkirane.

Missing Context

The PJD's 2021 defeat was historically dramatic—dropping from 125 seats to just 13 in parliament—but the narrative omits critical context: Morocco's monarchy retains ultimate political authority, and the 2021 election occurred amid widespread accusations of electoral manipulation and strategic voter redistricting. The PJD governed during 2011-2021 through a period when King Mohammed VI maintained constitutional supremacy over security, religious, and foreign policy matters. Additionally, the timing coincided with Morocco's normalization deal with Israel (brokered by the Trump administration), which the PJD initially opposed but was pressured to accept. The party's economic record during COVID-19, pension reform failures, and perception as ineffective against royal constraints all contributed to voter disillusionment.

Bias Analysis

Al Jazeera, owned by Qatar (which supports Islamist movements regionally), tends toward sympathetic framing of Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated parties like the PJD. The phrase "party with an Islamic reference" is notably soft terminology—Western outlets might use "Islamist" more directly. The focus on "rebuilding" and "regaining trust" suggests a redemption narrative rather than critical examination of why voters abandoned them. The monarchy's role in constraining or possibly undermining the PJD receives minimal emphasis in most such coverage.

Counter-Narratives

**Secularist perspective**: The PJD's decline represents Moroccan voters rejecting political Islam as ineffective governance, preferring technocratic administration over ideological platforms. Their decade in power produced little economic improvement while inserting religious conservatism into policy debates.

**Monarchy-aligned view**: The PJD was given opportunity to govern and failed on practical grounds—economic stagnation, unemployment, and administrative incompetence—not due to systemic sabotage. Their loss was democratic will, not manipulation.

**Regional analysts**: The PJD's fate mirrors broader Arab Spring reversals where Islamist parties gained power through democratic openings but either failed to deliver or were systematically undermined by entrenched state powers (see Egypt, Tunisia).

Alternative Angles (Speculative)

Some critics speculate that Morocco's monarchy orchestrated the PJD's electoral annihilation through behind-the-scenes electoral engineering, ensuring a compliant parliament after the party became too vocal on sovereignty issues. Fringe theories suggest the Israel normalization deal required sidelining the PJD as a condition, with Gulf states and Western intelligence allegedly coordinating to ensure their defeat. Others argue Benkirane's return is tacitly permitted by the palace as controlled opposition—a safety valve for Islamist sentiment that poses no real threat. These remain unproven assertions often circulating in Moroccan opposition circles and regional analysis forums.

Fact-Check Flags

What To Read Next